Thursday, March 6, 2014
Review: Song of the Spring Moon Waning by E. E. Ottoman
First, I adore the cover of this book. It's so well matched to the contents and that leaves me so excited. Second, this is a sweet love story between a eunuch and an intersex person that unfolded so beautifully, I want to know more!
Without giving away any spoilers, I wish there had been more exploration of intimacy between the two main characters. It came up briefly and I don't believe an intense scene like that would fit in the story's current format, but there was much emphasis put on Wen Yu's intersex nature and I wasn't satisfied with what little screen time that received.
However, the main reason I give 4 stars instead of 5 is due to the resolution of the story. The ending is not derived from the character's actions, but would have occurred regardless of the events that unfold from the main character's POV. There wouldn't be a love story, but the major conflict was rendered irrelevant when Mei Hua arrived.
But regardless, the craft of this story is so strong otherwise, and the characters so completely complex, that I would pick up a sequel without hesitation. Also, I just want to sit here and pet the cover.
TL;DR: 4stars. Deus Ex Machnia ending that's almost forgiven by such strong characters.